Korean J Pain 2023; 36(2): 149-162
Published online April 1, 2023 https://doi.org/10.3344/kjp.23080
Copyright © The Korean Pain Society.
Bo Rim Kim1 , Soo-Hyuk Yoon2 , Ho-Jin Lee2,3
1Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Korea University Guro Hospital, Korea University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
2Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Korea
3Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea
Correspondence to:Ho-Jin Lee
Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul National University College of Medicine, 101 Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul 03080, Korea
Tel: +82-2-2072-2467, Fax: +82-2-747-8363, E-mail: zenerdiode03@gmail.com
Handling Editor: Francis S. Nahm
Received: March 8, 2023; Revised: March 17, 2023; Accepted: March 18, 2023
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Chronic postsurgical pain (CPSP) is a multifactorial condition that affects a significant proportion of patients undergoing surgery. The prevention and management of CPSP require the identification of preoperative risk factors to screen high-risk patients and establish appropriate perioperative pain management plans to prevent its development. Active postoperative pain management should be provided to prevent CPSP in patients with severe pain following surgery. These tasks have become important for perioperative team members in the management of CPSP. This review article provides a comprehensive overview of the latest research on the role of perioperative team members in preventing and managing CPSP. Additionally, it highlights practical strategies that can be employed in clinical practice, covering the definition and risk factors for CPSP, including preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative factors, as well as a risk prediction model. The article also explores various treatments for CPSP, as well as preventive measures, including preemptive analgesia, regional anesthesia, pharmacological interventions, psychoeducational support, and surgical technique modification. This article emphasizes the importance of a comprehensive perioperative pain management plan that includes multidisciplinary interventions, using the transitional pain service as an example. By adopting a multidisciplinary and collaborative approach, perioperative team members can improve patient outcomes, enhance patient satisfaction, and reduce healthcare costs. However, further research is necessary to establish targeted interventions to effectively prevent and manage CPSP.
Keywords: Acute pain, Chronic Pain, Neuralgia, Pain Management, Pain, Postoperative, Perioperative Medicine, Postoperative Complications, Surgical Procedures, Operative.
Chronic postsurgical pain (CPSP) has become an important problem for perioperative team members as its high incidence rate has been continuously reported [1]. It is defined as pain that persists beyond the normal healing time after surgery and can last for months or even years [2]. Its prevalence varies depending on the type of surgery, but estimates suggest that up to more than 50% of patients may experience some degree of CPSP following certain procedures, such as thoracotomy, amputation, mastectomy, and hernia repair [3]. Moreover, while CPSP prevalence has been reported mainly in North America and some European countries, recent studies have shown its high prevalence in several East Asian countries [2,4–6].
The etiologies of CPSP are complex and multifactorial and can involve a variety of patient factors, including preoperative pain, psychological comorbidities, genetic predisposition, surgical and anesthetic techniques, and perioperative management [1]. While much research has focused on identifying the risk factors for CPSP, there is growing recognition that perioperative problems, such as inadequate perioperative pain and psychological stress management, can also contribute to the development of this condition [7–10]. Therefore, perioperative team members have a critical role to play in the management of CPSP. The role of perioperative team members in the management of CPSP is multifaceted and involves a range of interventions, from preoperative patient education and risk assessment to the use of multimodal analgesia techniques and other interventional therapies. In addition, perioperative team members must be attuned to the psychological and social factors that can impact a patient's pain experience by collaborating with other departments to develop a comprehensive perioperative pain management plan.
This review article explores the latest research on the role of perioperative team members in the prevention and management of CPSP, with a focus on practical strategies that can be employed in clinical practice. Through an examination of the current evidence and best practices, this article aimed to provide perioperative team members with the knowledge and tools needed to effectively manage CPSP and improve postoperative outcomes.
Perioperative team members need to know the diagnostic criteria for CPSP because it is a common complication of surgery that can significantly impact a patient's quality of life. Understanding the diagnostic criteria for CPSP can help physicians anticipate the risk of developing this complication after surgery, accurately diagnose and manage patients who develop CPSP, and provide appropriate pain management strategies to optimize postoperative outcomes. The use of standardized diagnostic criteria is also crucial for facilitating the comparison of treatment effects in research studies.
The concept of CPSP was first proposed in 1998 by Crombie et al. [11], who attempted to determine the contribution of surgery and trauma to chronic pain. Since then, several researchers have suggested or supplemented the diagnostic criteria for CPSP [12–14], and have contributed to the creation of the latest definition of CPSP as presented in the International Classification of Diseases, 11th Revision [15] (Table 1). The following criteria have most recently been used to define CPSP: 1) chronic pain that develops or increases in intensity after a surgical procedure and persists beyond the healing process, that is, at least 3 months after surgery; 2) the pain may be localized to the surgical field, projected to the innervation territory of a nerve situated in this area, or referred to a dermatome (after surgery/injury to deep somatic or visceral tissues); 3) other causes of pain, including infection and malignancy, must be excluded, as well as pain that continues from a pre-existing pain problem; and 4) depending on the type of surgery, CPSP often has a neuropathic component [15].
Table 1 Contribution of previous literature to the latest definition of chronic postsurgical pain in the ICD-11
Literature | Macrae [12] | Werner and Kongsgaard [13] | Treede et al. [14] | Schug et al. [15] |
---|---|---|---|---|
Temporal relationship with surgery | The pain develops after the surgery | The pain develops or increases in intensity after the surgery | The pain develops after the surgery | The pain develops or increases in intensity after the surgery |
Duration of pain after surgery | At least 2 months’ duration | At least 3–6 months’ duration | At least 3 months’ duration | |
Exclusion of other causes | Other causes of pain need to be excluded; pain continuing from a pre-existing pain-related condition should also be excluded | Other causes of pain need to be excluded | Other causes of pain need to be excluded; pain continuing from a pre-existing pain-related condition should also be excluded | |
Location of pain | - | The pain is either localized to the surgical field, projected to the innervation territory of a nerve situated in this area, or referred to a dermatome | - | The pain is either localized to the surgical field, projected to the innervation territory of a nerve situated in this area, or referred to a dermatome |
Others | - | The pain is either a continuation of acute postsurgical pain or develops after an asymptomatic period | CPSP is often neuropathic |
CPSP: chronic postsurgical pain, ICD-11: International Classification of Diseases, 11th Revision.
It is important for perioperative team members to identify the risk factors for CPSP in managing surgical patients because these factors can help predict the likelihood of developing CPSP after surgery. By identifying high-risk patients, perioperative team members can take preventive measures and provide targeted interventions to reduce the incidence and severity of CPSP. Furthermore, understanding the risk factors can help physicians optimize pain management strategies for each patient and tailor treatment plans based on individual patient characteristics to minimize the risk of developing CPSP and improve postoperative outcomes.
Some patient factors, such as female sex, younger age, and obesity, are well-known risk factors for CPSP [1,16,17]. Another key predisposing factor for developing CPSP is preoperative pain at the site of the surgery or other parts of the body [1,3]. A multicenter study on inguinal hernia, hysterectomy, and thoracotomy showed that preoperative remote pain, as well as surgical area pain, was a significant risk factor for CPSP [18]. Patients with preoperative pain, regardless of the site, have a significantly higher risk of developing CPSP after radical prostatectomy or nephrectomy [19,20]. Chronic painful conditions in other parts of the body, such as fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome, or migraines also show significant associations with CPSP development [1,3]. Furthermore, preoperative opioid use for chronic pain is likely to be closely related to the development of CPSP [21–23]. Recently, the influence of genetics on pain sensitivity and CPSP development has also been extensively investigated; however, it requires further research before it can be applied to actual clinical practice [18,24–26].
In addition to the aforementioned unmodifiable or difficult-to-modify factors, other potentially modifiable preoperative risk factors have also been discussed. Psychological factors, including anxiety, depression, catastrophizing, and general stress levels, have consistently been reported as predictors of CPSP [10,27] and are also important targets for the prevention of CPSP, which will be discussed later.
Operative factors, such as the type and duration of the surgery, extensive surgery, and extent of nerve damage, are known to be among the most important predictors of CPSP [1]. Thoracotomy, mastectomy, amputation, and orthopedic surgeries have been regarded as high-risk surgeries for CPSP development, with an incidence of approximately 50% [28,29]. Laparoscopic procedures have generally been associated with a lower incidence of CPSP compared to open procedures [1]; however, the evidence is not entirely consistent [30]. Some studies have found a significant reduction in CPSP with laparoscopic surgery, whereas others have found no difference between laparoscopic and open procedures [1,30].
The influence of anesthetic techniques on CPSP is relatively unknown. A recent multinational randomized controlled trial showed no significant intergroup difference in CPSP between a regional anesthesia-analgesia group (paravertebral block and propofol) and a general anesthesia group (inhalation anesthesia with an opioid) [31]. However, some studies predict it to be relevant. An animal study reported that general anesthetics activate a key nociceptive ion channel and enhance nerve-mediated postoperative pain [32]. Exposure to intraoperative high-dose opioids and analgesics of choice for intraoperative and postoperative analgesia may induce pain hypersensitivity
The intensity and duration of acute postoperative pain are among the strongest and most consistent risk factors of CPSP [1,3,40,41]. The correlation between severe acute postoperative pain and CPSP has been clearly identified in various operation types, including thoracotomy, breast surgery, hernia repair, and hip arthroplasty [42–44]. Recent studies have found that patients with non-ideal acute pain trajectories after surgery were associated with a higher incidence of CPSP compared to those with ideal trajectories, which show expected improvements in postoperative pain [45,46]. If acute pain is not adequately managed, it can lead to changes in the nervous system, including sensitization of pain pathways, which can result in chronic pain that persists long after the surgical site has healed [3]. Additionally, uncontrolled acute pain can cause physical and psychological distress, contributing to the development of CPSP. Therefore, effective management of acute postoperative pain is important to prevent the development of CPSP. This may include a multimodal approach to pain management, such as using a combination of medications, nerve blocks, and non-pharmacological interventions such as cognitive therapies. In addition to the management of acute postoperative pain, other postoperative complications, reoperations, and adjuvant cancer therapies have been associated with a higher incidence of CPSP [1,47,48].
Risk prediction models for CPSP that are applicable in clinical settings may help screen high-risk patients and provide individualized preventive strategies. Several risk prediction models have been developed and validated [1]; however, a recent systematic review focused on the high risk of bias in previous models [49]. Montes et al. [18,50] developed and validated a 6-item predictive model for four surgical procedures, including hernia repair, vaginal or abdominal hysterectomy, and thoracotomy. This model includes only preoperative factors, such as surgical procedure, age, physical and mental health, and preoperative pain in the surgical field and another area with a moderate discrimination efficacy [50]. Meretoja et al. [51] developed and validated a 4-item predictive model for patients undergoing breast cancer surgery, including preoperative pain in the surgical area, high body mass index, axillary lymph node dissection, and pain intensity on postoperative day 7. Since this model contains a postoperative factor, preoperative screening with this predictive model is not possible. Recently, a predictive model was developed and validated in a prospective cohort of patients undergoing orthopedic, vascular, trauma, and general surgery [52]. The final model included four predictors: preoperative opioid use, bone surgery, pain score on postoperative day 14, and the presence of a painful cold within the painful area 2 weeks after surgery, with a reported area under the curve of 0.82. The neuropathic characteristics of pain were shown to be strong predictors of CPSP development in this model, supporting the neuropathic mechanism with nervous system sensitization [52]. In addition to the development of a more accurate prediction model for CPSP, future research is needed to determine whether CPSP can be reduced when the prediction model is used in clinical practice. Moreover, predicting the risk of CPSP can have economic benefits by enabling the targeted allocation of limited medical resources to patients in need of intensive care.
Acute postoperative pain is a major modifiable contributor to the development of CPSP and has been considered a key target for preventive interventions. Efforts to prevent CPSP typically begin with the management of acute postoperative pain. Although the underlying mechanisms are not yet fully understood, nociceptive sensitization and structural changes in the central nervous system appear to lower the mechanical threshold and exacerbate the response to noxious stimuli [3,35,53,54]. Furthermore, as perioperative team members also have a vital role in the management of acute postoperative pain, their contribution to the prevention of CPSP can be enhanced through the improvement of acute postoperative pain management.
Preemptive analgesia, which has recently been used as an option for multimodal analgesia, can prevent CPSP and reduce acute postoperative pain [55]. The concept of preemptive analgesia was first suggested by Woolf et al. [56] in 1993. This technique involves providing analgesia before surgical incision to block the noxious preoperative stimulus and prevent the activation of primary afferent nociceptors. The association between preemptive analgesia and CPSP prevention has been explored in several studies. For instance, a randomized controlled trial on thoracotomy divided 69 patients into three groups: the pre-thoracic epidural analgesia (TEA) group (epidural analgesia from preoperative to postoperative period), a post-TEA group (epidural analgesia during the postoperative period), and an intravenous patient-controlled analgesia group (postoperative intravenous analgesia) [57]. The severity of acute postoperative pain and the incidence and severity of CPSP, evaluated after 6 months, significantly decreased in the pre-TEA group compared with those in the other two groups [57]. Another study comparing pre-incisional paravertebral blocks and sham blocks in breast surgery showed a significant difference in acute postoperative pain and pain evaluated at 1, 6, and 12 months after surgery [58]. In a randomized controlled trial on phantom limb pain, the incidence of CPSP was significantly reduced by using intravenous or epidural analgesia starting 48 hours before surgery [59]. Recently, a meta-analysis reported that preemptive epidural analgesia before surgical incision reduced the incidence of CPSP after thoracotomy compared to epidural analgesia after incision [60]. Proper pain management at the right time during the perioperative period may lead to better outcomes for preventing CPSP.
The anesthetic agents used during general anesthesia may have an impact on the development of CPSP. Propofol-based anesthesia has been suggested to decrease the incidence of CPSP compared with inhalation-based anesthesia [38,61,62]. Nitrous oxide, an NMDA receptor antagonist, has also been reported to reduce CPSP [63]. However, in a follow-up study of a large-scale multicenter trial, nitrous oxide did not demonstrate any significant difference in the incidence of CPSP at 12 months after surgery, except in patients with variants in the methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase gene [64]. As high-dose opioid exposure during surgery is widely recognized as a risk factor for CPSP [65], individualized tailoring of the opioid dose with intraoperative nociception monitors may potentially be helpful in preventing CPSP [66].
Regional block techniques in various surgeries have been shown to be effective in preventing the development of CPSP. Although the mechanism is not completely understood, it appears to modulate pain signals and neuroplasticity, thereby decreasing central sensitization and pain chronification [67]. In systematic reviews comparing regional anesthesia with conventional analgesia, thoracic epidural anesthesia in thoracotomy seems to effectively reduce CPSP [68,69]. However, a recent meta-analysis has reported that thoracic paravertebral block is not effective in preventing CPSP following thoracic surgery [70]. The use of regional analgesia or local anesthetics
Aggressive pharmacological interventions to prevent CPSP seem promising; however, evidence in this field has shown somewhat disappointing results. Intraoperative ketamine appears to be beneficial for the control of acute postoperative pain; however, its impact on chronic pain remains controversial [4,28,79,80]. Recently, a large multicenter randomized controlled trial regarding the effectiveness of ketamine on CPSP has been actively conducted in Australia, and the results are expected soon [81]. Gabapentinoids, antidepressants, and local anesthetics, such as intravenous and topical lidocaine, have also been reported to be effective in reducing CPSP [28]. However, the most recent meta-analysis concluded that the effects of these drugs were smaller than expected, and their clinical implications were unclear [82].
Although pharmacological approaches have been the mainstay of interventions to prevent CPSP, the aspect of psychoeducation has recently been focused on. As previously described, preoperative psychological problems are a consistent risk factor for CPSP. In this regard, providing accurate information to patients and lowering anxiety levels through preoperative psychoeducation may help prevent the progression to chronic pain [83]. One meta-analysis, which included 15 randomized controlled trials, reported that active perioperative psychotherapy reduced the severity of CPSP and improved physical impairment [84]. Psychoeducational interventions have been an important component of the multimodal approach in the transitional pain service (TPS) at Toronto General Hospital throughout the perioperative period, which has been shown to decrease CPSP and opioid consumption [85].
Operative risk factors, such as the type of surgery and the duration of the procedure, are critical but difficult-to-modify factors that can affect the development of CPSP. Less invasive surgeries are expected to cause less chronic pain because nerve injury caused by dissection or retraction of the tissue is a crucial risk factor for CPSP [86]. In this regard, laparoscopic surgeries, such as herniorrhaphy or cholecystectomy, have shown less progression to CPSP than open surgery [1]. However, in a study comparing thoracotomy and video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS), the two groups did not show significant differences in CPSP-related outcomes 1 year after the operation [87]. A nationwide questionnaire study also showed a comparable incidence of CPSP between patients undergoing VATS and thoracotomy [88], possibly due to intercostal nerve damage occurring in both groups, which is a significant risk factor for chronic neuropathic pain [89]. However, with the evolution of operational techniques, a recent study showed that single-port VATS, with a smaller surgical incision, reduced the incidence of CPSP compared with multi-port VATS [90].
The treatment of established CPSP has been addressed relatively less than its prevention. However, considering its high prevalence and clinical impact on quality of life after surgery, its treatment should also be considered an important issue among perioperative team members.
CPSP, diagnosed after excluding other causes of pain, can be treated with various pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments, similar to other chronic pain conditions. As in the recently proposed modified World Health Organization analgesic ladder for chronic non-cancer pain, the intensity of analgesic medications can be upgraded step-by-step depending on the patient's response to treatment, starting with a non-opioid analgesic method [91]. Strong opioids should be used carefully in a limited number of patients in the last step, weighing their benefits and risks [92]. In addition, since the prevalence of the neuropathic component in CPSP has been known to be high [93,94], various pharmacologic and interventional treatments used for neuropathic pain can be useful in the treatment of CPSP [95]. A recently reported comprehensive algorithm for neuropathic pain has suggested non-opioid medications such as tricyclic antidepressants, serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, gabapentinoids, topicals, and transdermal substances as first-line therapy and tramadol and tapentadol as second-line therapy [96]. Moreover, their effects have also been reported in patients with CPSP [97]. Psychological interventions are also considered an important option in the treatment of CPSP because psychological factors have been consistently reported as important risk factors for CPSP [21]. According to a systematic review, preliminary evidence suggests that psychological interventions based on cognitive behavioral therapy can reduce the intensity and disability associated with CPSP [98]. Furthermore, the effectiveness of neuromodulation techniques, such as radiofrequency ablation and spinal cord stimulation, has been reported in various surgeries [99–106]. Considering the neuropathic component underlying CPSP, neuromodulation is expected to be an important therapeutic option for patients who are non-responsive to pharmacological interventions.
However, there is still a lack of evidence regarding the treatment of CPSP. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, only one systematic review has reported on this issue thus far [97]. Unfortunately, a meta-analysis was not conducted because of the heterogeneity of the study [97]. Therefore, the authors concluded that all interventions had insufficient evidence to support the conclusion of their effectiveness. To improve the management of CPSP, robust evidence should be provided by conducting well-designed studies on this issue, as well as researching the prediction and prevention of CPSP in the future.
The TPS, launched in 2014 at the Toronto General Hospital, provides comprehensive perioperative pain management from the preoperative to the post-discharge phase [85]. Its main goal is to minimize the transition of acute postoperative pain to CPSP. To this end, TPSs provide multidisciplinary pain management in patients whose acute pain is likely to be uncontrolled after surgery or in patients with a high possibility of developing CPSP preoperatively.
TPS can be divided into three stages depending on the timing of the intervention (preoperative, immediate postoperative in-hospital, and postoperative in outpatient settings) [85]. First, the risk of developing CPSP is assessed preoperatively, and a personalized perioperative pain management plan is established based on the level of risk. In addition, psychological consultation and patient and caregiver education can be provided. Second, immediately after surgery, acute postoperative pain is actively controlled using a multimodal approach by a multidisciplinary pain management team. Finally, the outpatient visit schedule is adjusted by phone within 3 days of surgery, and usually, a follow-up appointment is scheduled in the outpatient clinic within 2–3 weeks after discharge. If the patient has difficulty controlling the pain, the schedule can be rescheduled. Outpatient clinics offer a comprehensive approach to pain management, which includes multidisciplinary interventions, such as psychological intervention and physiotherapy. Some studies have indicated that TPS is effective in alleviating postoperative pain and in reducing opioid use after discharge [107,108]. Recent reports also suggest that implementing TPS for various surgical patients resulted in a substantial reduction in the severity of CPSP and opioid consumption after discharge [109–112]. Moreover, implementing TPSs is expected to be economically feasible by reducing the social costs associated with CPSP, such as loss of productivity and treatment expenses [113].
However, currently, only a limited number of institutions have implemented TPS. The scarcity of resources and manpower in the medical environment may make it challenging to provide such services in the near future. Under these circumstances, pain physicians at pain centers, trained in anesthesiology and pain medicine, are expected to play a vital role in managing patients with CPSP in collaboration with perioperative team members. Pain physicians possess extensive knowledge of perioperative care, as well as expertise in treating chronic neuropathic pain, making them valuable partners in the management of CPSP. Therefore, perioperative team members should collaborate with pain physicians to provide a continuous set of treatments for patients with CPSP. This collaborative approach would allow for the provision of comprehensive care and the management of the complex needs of patients with CPSP.
As demonstrated in Fig. 1, perioperative team members can play a crucial role in managing CPSP, and should take into account its high prevalence and impact on patients' quality of life. To prevent and manage CPSP, perioperative team members should first evaluate the preoperative risk factors of each patient. For high-risk patients, perioperative team members must establish preventive interventions that offer multidisciplinary approaches, including psychoeducation, in addition to the institution's routine protocol. Second, to minimize the risk factors of CPSP, perioperative team members should establish a multimodal opioid-sparing analgesia regimen, which would reduce both acute postoperative pain severity and perioperative opioid use. Moreover, patients who experience acute postoperative pain that is not alleviated by the routine perioperative pain management protocol should receive additional treatment, including a referral to a pain specialist, within a multidisciplinary system. Finally, it is essential to establish a system that provides appropriate treatment even after discharge for high-risk patients susceptible to developing CPSP. This system should incorporate a follow-up care plan that emphasizes early identification and intervention for CPSP.
In summary, CPSP is a multifactorial and complex condition that can significantly affect the quality of life of patients undergoing surgery. The implementation of a comprehensive perioperative pain management plan that includes multidisciplinary interventions is essential to reduce the incidence and severity of CPSP. The establishment of an integrated management plan for CPSP that involves the cooperation of perioperative team members in various departments is crucial for optimizing patient outcomes and minimizing the social costs associated with this condition. Future research should focus on identifying patient-specific risk factors for CPSP and developing targeted interventions to prevent and manage CPSP effectively. By addressing CPSP using a multidisciplinary and collaborative approach, caregivers can enhance patient satisfaction, reduce healthcare costs, and improve patient outcomes after surgery.
Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed in this study.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
No funding to declare.
Bo Rim Kim: Writing/manuscript preparation; Soo-Hyuk Yoon: Investigation; Ho-Jin Lee: Writing/manuscript preparation.